Hey Delusion!

by Mogogo - October 16th, 2006
why read this?!fairly good.interesting...GREAT READ!oh give us MORE of this!!! ( no ratings yet )
Loading ... Loading ...

It occured to me today that everyone thinks they are doing the right thing. The idea came to me as i was puzzling over the actions of an erstwhile friend. When trying to figure out why she would act that way, trying to understand how she could reconcile her actions with those of a good person, it struck me that she actually thinks she is doing the right thing.

Is that right? Do we all actually think we are doing the right thing? The mind is an incredibly powerful tool, and moral relativism is a good way of justifying pretty much anything.

So I got thinking. I’m no saint, but I can’t think of the last time i did something consciously bad. I can think of lots of bad things that I have done, but its often only later, much later, that that realisation strikes me.

Perhaps no one does anything they know to be bad. This is a much more scary idea than it at first appears. What if Hitler thought he was doing the right thing? You know, i reckon he probably did…

If this is true, there are some important lessons to be drawn:

  1. Its useful to reflect on our actions, post facto. While in the middle of a situation, at least for me, its all too easy to convince myself that i am in fact doing the right thing. Its harder to so convince with the passage of some time. Eventually, some of that ability to stop deluding myself might spill over into my present actions rather than just my reflections on the past. 
  2. But even then, how can you judge right from wrong? A set of firm, resolute moral laws is a good thing. Having a moral code, with some authority behind it, gives a benchmark against which one can judge one’s actions. That doesnt mean you will always do the right thing, but at least you will know when you are doing the wrong thing.

Perhaps i’m alone in this. Perhaps you either do no wrong, or don’t indulge in my self-delusion. But if you do, tell me how else one can at least tell the difference between right and wrong…

5 Responses to “Hey Delusion!”

  1. Hannibal says:

    You already know when you do something wrong otherwise you would not being having this conversation with yourself. You get the rules where you can. Satre said that “nothing is vouchsafed’ and this still holds true. If you’re actions stand to hurt one person that that is clearly wrong, but if they stand to hurt a million people then that is, a la Stalin, merely a statistic. You can’t please all the poeple all the time but you can please some of the people some of the time. Pick your friends carefully but pick your enemies even more carefully…they have longer memories and longer arms.

  2. Misagh says:

    Thanks for this posting Mogogo.

    This phenomenon of delusional faith in one’s own grey matter is something that i have pondered on since being a wee lad. Why, I’d ask myself whilst musing over Roald Dahl or body slamming one G.I. Joe into another, is it that everyone believes in whatever it is that they think?

    The world was flat, definitely flat. And no doubt of its physical centrality in the scheme of all created and no-created things, for why else would Christ grace it with His presence? Those with a hint of melanin in their skin were savages, primitives, sure they were and no buts about it. A woman with a stance was a witch and fit for naught but the infinite abyss of hell (which of course, was and is, a very very hot place), for why else would she display intellect or an opinion? It’s a war we had to have, for sure. And no, no way is poison bad for the earth or for our children. Of course it isn’t. Computers are for NASA, no one will find a use for one nor fit one in a normally proportioned house. And this internet mumbo jumbo will never come to any use.

    And yet, with a whole history of ludicrous “definites” behind us, we persist: My god is better than yours, and when he comes back it will be in a pyramid led by white horses on the backdrop of a melting sun, and then you’ll be sorry. This molecule is what causes disease, and that’s that. And I’m sad and that’s why God doesn’t exist, for why would a white man live in a cloud anyhow? Objects travel in straight lines, and why would you be stupid enough to challenge that?

    This is why my virtue of patience is challenged when someone says “I don’t believe in that, fullstop.” “If everyone just thought as I do there would be no wars.” Or “I believe in science.” As if I don’t - Science believes in its expanding frontiers, not only in its current self.

    Friends and fellow humans, let’s learn from history and hold our horses on closed conclusions. Let’s admit that the 10% of a brain that we might use, with our own limited experience and sub-universal perception, cannot know all. This is why I agree with Mogogo, that a common code beyond our own selves gives us something to work towards.

    But on the question of whether we all act according to what our conscience dictates as good, I’m not so sure about that. Sometimes grave evils and injustices are committed by minds that either pretend that it’s good, or get a kick out of harming others, feeding their own insecurity. In the corporate world it’s a daily occurence for people to deceive to get ahead of others. Competition driven by jealousy or want cannot be driven by conscience, rather desire.

    Hurting others inadverdently whilst we mean to do good is another matter. It is not just that one person commits the act, but that another finds offence. Life is too short and our taking offence a waste of precious time. As it has been said, “Life is a dwarf, don’t be offended.” Okay, so nobody said that.

  3. Mogogo says:

    This discussion is continued in the “We dont know nothing” post above.

  4. Saleem says:

    “Sartre said that ‘nothing is vouchsafed” and this still holds true.” - I am sure that Sartre, at least, spotted the irony and contradiction.

  5. Hey Delusion! « Moving Form says:

    […] Yesterday on a blog I frequent, a certain Neocrat named Mogogo posted commentary about a pet topic of mine (ask my wife, I get quite animated by it): Why it is that everyone thinks what they think is right? Called Hey Delusion! it has sparked some interesting discussion.My comments on this topic were promoted status homepagicus (Shucks, Oscar the Neocrat, I’m chuffed) and if it’s good enough for them it’s good enough for this humble blog: We don’t know nothing […]

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

all content
© by The Neocrats .
design & code
© by nemoDreaming.com.

The Neocrats is proudly powered by WordPress.

Feeds:
Entries (RSS), Comments (RSS)

. 2009 Medical Weblog adult downloads